What a Hint Should Never Say

Hint text fails in predictable ways. Here are the four failures I see most often, and what to do instead.

The Hint Room · 323 words

I collect bad hint text the way other people collect bad headlines. The failures repeat, and each one has a simple fix. Four of them are worth naming.

The first is the compliment. "You're close!" is not information unless the player knows what close means. Close in letters? Close in distance to the target? The phrase feels supportive and leaves the player exactly where they were, now slightly more confused.

The second is the riddle. Some hint writers replace a plain nudge with wordplay, presumably to preserve the challenge. But the player has already decided to accept help. Making help itself a puzzle is just a second puzzle, and a worse one, because it has no rules the player can reason about.

The third is the lecture. A paragraph of explanation is not a hint. Hints should be short enough to hold in working memory while you try the next move. If you cannot remember it without scrolling back, it is an article.

The fourth is the premature answer. It is the most common failure and the easiest to fix: the first tier gives a word. There is nothing left to decide, so the player finishes the puzzle without playing it. The fix is to move that tier down one level and write a narrower one above it.

A good hint says one true thing about where the player's plan is, in one sentence, and then gets out of the way. If you want to see a set of hints that mostly obeys this, the graded hints are a decent reference. If you just want to play and are tired of being told you are close when you are not, click here and take the first tier on the first loop you hit.

Hint writing looks like a small craft. It is the part of a puzzle players remember longest, because it is the part that shows up when the puzzle is hard.