The best hints leave you better at the next puzzle. Three properties that make help educational.
Most help systems optimise for the current puzzle. The better ones optimise for the next one. The difference shows up in three properties, and none of them is about how much information a hint gives.
The first property is local truth. A hint should say something true about the specific rung the player is on, not about ladders in general. General advice belongs in a how-to page. Local truth is what the player can verify immediately by trying the next move, and verification is how learning happens.
The second is a visible consequence. After taking the hint, the player should be able to see what changed in their plan. If the hint points at a branch, the branch should be examinable. If it names a letter, the player should be able to test words against it. A hint whose effect you cannot observe is just trivia.
The third is reuse. The most useful hints teach a pattern the player will meet again: a dictionary boundary, a common end shape, a kind of dead end. When you browse the archive after a hint, you can often find the pattern in older puzzles. That is the moment help turns into practice.
Taken together, those properties explain why a good hint feels different from an answer. An answer ends the puzzle. A hint that teaches ends a question and leaves a pattern behind, and the pattern is the thing that actually improves play.
If you want to test a help layer, play a puzzle with one hint and then replay an old one without hints. If the hint shows up in the replay, it taught you something. If it does not, it was only a shortcut. Free practice makes the experiment easy, because you can play the same kind of board as many times as you like.
This is a small design principle with a long shadow. Games that teach through their help layers are played for years; games that only reveal are finished.